Seoul: The government and Democratic Party of South Korea have embarked on a significant overhaul of the nation's economic criminal law. Out of the more than 6,000 business-related offenses, they are set to revise 110 in the initial phase, with amendments to be presented during the current National Assembly session. The primary objective is to alleviate the excessive criminal penalties that have been a deterrent to business activity and have negatively impacted the economy. President Lee Jae Myung, on September 7, directed the administration to reduce economic criminal statutes by 30 percent within the year.
According to Yonhap News Agency, one of the most prominent steps in this reform is the abolition of the breach of trust provision in the Criminal Act. This provision has long been a catch-all charge due to its vague wording and broad application, which has left business leaders vulnerable to prosecution. Prosecutors have often arbitrarily decided on indictments, leading to inconsistent court rulings. The Korea Enterprises Federation (KEF) recently reported that only 14.8 percent of breach of trust complaints resulted in indictments, significantly lower than the overall criminal indictment rate of 39.1 percent. Furthermore, the acquittal rates for these cases were more than twice that of other crimes, highlighting the issue of frivolous complaints.
The reform of these statutes is timely, especially as amendments to the Commercial Act, which strengthen shareholder duties and introduce the pro-labor "Yellow Envelope Bill," are already placing a burden on companies. Eliminating legal provisions that obstruct normal business operations is a step towards creating a more predictable business environment. The KEF expressed hope that this initiative would lay the groundwork for broader regulatory reform, ensuring that business concerns are considered in the process.
However, the removal of the breach of trust provision should not serve as a shield for politicians or unethical executives. Opponents argue that the reform could effectively become a law to "save President Lee Jae Myung," who is currently facing breach of trust charges in court. To dispel such suspicions, lawmakers must ensure that replacement legislation clearly defines the subjects and requirements, closing any loopholes that might allow politicians to escape accountability.
The rationalization of economic criminal law is merely a starting point. Old practices, such as calling business leaders as witnesses to humiliate them during audits, continue to exist. The current revisions address only 1.6 percent of all such statutes. For South Korea to become a more attractive destination for investment, the government must develop a fair and predictable legal framework and expedite regulatory reforms. The focus should be on achieving tangible results that restore confidence in the business environment, rather than making symbolic gestures.